Isobornyl ester plasticizer data in PVC
Isobornyl ester plasticizer candidates made from camphene and C12 to C18 fatty acids were tested in PVC at 20, 40 and 60 phr. The isobornyl stearate grade at 60 phr lowered the glass transition to 31 degrees Celsius, while the DOP control reached 456% elongation. Tensile strength fell relative to neat PVC in most formulations, and some grades showed no plasticizing effect at all. The series was clearly formulation dependent.
Why test this isobornyl ester plasticizer family for PVC
PVC needs a plasticizer that lowers the glass transition, keeps the compound flexible and survives processing temperatures. Phthalate grades have dominated that role, which is why non-phthalate and bio-derived alternatives keep attracting attention. Camphene is a terpene available from pine-derived feedstocks. Esterifying it with long-chain fatty acids gives a family of molecules with a bulky isobornyl head and a variable alkyl tail.
The question in this work was practical: do these esters actually plasticize PVC, and does chain length in the acid part matter? Ester identity and loading both changed the answer in ways the family name alone would not predict. An isobornyl ester plasticizer cannot be judged from its chemical family name alone.
How the esters were made and the compounds were prepared
The synthesis used camphene, C12 to C18 fatty acids and titanium sulfate. The camphene feed contained 79.8% camphene and 17.3% tricyclic terpene. Titanium sulfate was at least 96% pure and each fatty acid at least 98%. Products were identified by gas chromatography and mass spectrometry and confirmed by proton and carbon nuclear magnetic resonance.
Four esters were prepared, covering laurate, myristate, palmitate and stearate chains. Each was compounded with PVC at three loadings.
Ester | Abbreviation | Loadings tested | PVC to ester ratios |
Isobornyl laurate | IL | 20, 40, 60 phr | 100:20, 100:40, 100:60 |
Isobornyl myristate | IM | 20, 40, 60 phr | 100:20, 100:40, 100:60 |
Isobornyl palmitate | IP | 20, 40, 60 phr | 100:20, 100:40, 100:60 |
Isobornyl stearate | IS | 20, 40, 60 phr | 100:20, 100:40, 100:60 |
Neat PVC control | none | 0 phr | 100:0 |
DOP control | DOP | 60 phr | 100:60 |
A representative 40 phr formulation used 2.0 g PVC resin and 0.8 g plasticizer in 40 mL tetrahydrofuran. The mixture was stirred at 50 degrees Celsius for 30 to 60 minutes until clear, cast into an 80 by 60 by 4 mm mold, dried at 25 degrees Celsius for 48 hours and then at 50 degrees Celsius for 12 hours. The resulting strips were about 0.20 mm thick.
Test | Conditions reported |
Tensile | GB/T 1040.1-2006, 25 degrees Celsius, 10 mm per minute, five parallel specimens |
Thermogravimetry | Nitrogen atmosphere, 10 degrees Celsius per minute, 40 to 600 degrees Celsius |
Differential scanning calorimetry | Hold at minus 60 degrees Celsius, ramp to 120 degrees Celsius at 20 degrees Celsius per minute, cool back, reheat |
Tensile results: strength falls, elongation is inconsistent
Neat PVC had a tensile strength of 35.00 MPa and 149.00% elongation at break. The DOP control at 60 phr reached 25.00 MPa and 456% elongation. The isobornyl esters sat between those behaviors, but not in a simple order.
Formulation | Tensile strength (MPa) | Elongation at break (%) |
Neat PVC | 35.00 +/- 0.70 | 149.00 +/- 4.50 |
PVC-DOP 60 phr | 25.00 +/- 1.53 | 456 +/- 3.68 |
IL-20 | 18.93 +/- 0.57 | 329.10 +/- 6.59 |
IL-40 | 32.46 +/- 0.64 | 448.10 +/- 4.48 |
IL-60 | 29.67 +/- 1.28 | 275.49 +/- 5.51 |
IM-20 | 10.91 +/- 0.65 | 73.16 +/- 5.85 |
IM-40 | 15.28 +/- 0.76 | 44.35 +/- 1.76 |
IM-60 | 27.77 +/- 0.83 | 351.39 +/- 7.03 |
IP-20 | 16.67 +/- 0.20 | 247.00 +/- 4.94 |
IP-40 | 15.05 +/- 0.75 | 281.70 +/- 11.27 |
IP-60 | 13.91 +/- 0.70 | 384.90 +/- 3.85 |
IS-20 | 31.42 +/- 0.63 | 178.83 +/- 8.94 |
IS-40 | 34.39 +/- 2.06 | 286.59 +/- 8.60 |
IS-60 | 24.88 +/- 1.00 | 167.66 +/- 10.06 |
Every ester formulation reduced tensile strength relative to neat PVC, and elongation did not rise monotonically with loading. Isobornyl laurate at 40 phr reached 448.10% elongation, close to the DOP control, but at 60 phr it fell back to 275.49%. Isobornyl myristate at 20 and 40 phr gave elongation below neat PVC, at 73.16% and 44.35%, before rising to 351.39% at 60 phr. A single phr number therefore cannot describe the family.
Glass transition: the 60 phr window
Differential scanning calorimetry showed a monotonic drop in glass transition as ester loading increased within each family. The lowest values appeared at 60 phr.
Ester | Tg at 20 phr | Tg at 40 phr | Tg at 60 phr |
Isobornyl laurate | 59 degrees Celsius | 43 degrees Celsius | 39 degrees Celsius |
Isobornyl myristate | 48 degrees Celsius | 46 degrees Celsius | 33 degrees Celsius |
Isobornyl palmitate | 63 degrees Celsius | 49 degrees Celsius | 38 degrees Celsius |
Isobornyl stearate | 56 degrees Celsius | 42 degrees Celsius | 31 degrees Celsius |
At a PVC to ester ratio of 100:60, the glass transition fell to between 31 and 39 degrees Celsius. All measured values remained above the 25 degrees Celsius tensile test temperature. The isobornyl stearate grade gave the lowest Tg, which fits with its longer alkyl chain, but the tensile results show that a low Tg did not translate into the best elongation.
Thermal stability: the esters leave before PVC decomposes
Thermogravimetry gives a separate warning for anyone processing these esters at PVC temperatures. Neat PVC showed three weight-loss stages: 40 to 162 degrees Celsius for residual solvent and water, 281 to 400 degrees Celsius for main-chain degradation, and above 400 degrees Celsius for carbonization and polycyclic aromatic breakdown.
Plasticized samples showed an additional weight-loss interval between 190 and 260 degrees Celsius, assigned to volatilization and ester-bond decomposition of the isobornyl esters. Peak temperatures were 222 degrees Celsius for laurate, 231 degrees Celsius for myristate, and 237 degrees Celsius for both palmitate and stearate. Isobornyl alcohol has a boiling point of 212 degrees Celsius.
Grade | Ester loss peak | Separation from main PVC degradation |
Isobornyl laurate | 222 degrees Celsius | 40 to 50 degrees Celsius window |
Isobornyl myristate | 231 degrees Celsius | 40 to 50 degrees Celsius window |
Isobornyl palmitate | 237 degrees Celsius | 40 to 50 degrees Celsius window |
Isobornyl stearate | 237 degrees Celsius | 40 to 50 degrees Celsius window |
The reported peak-to-peak difference between ester loss and PVC decomposition was 40 to 50 degrees Celsius, a narrow processing margin. The authors also note that the esters partially decompose in that interval rather than simply evaporating unchanged.
The counterintuitive part: lower Tg did not mean better elongation
Screening often treats Tg reduction as a proxy for efficiency. This dataset does not support that shortcut. The stearate grade at 60 phr produced the lowest Tg at 31 degrees Celsius, yet its elongation at break was 167.66%, well below the 456% reached by the DOP control and below the laurate grade at 40 phr. Myristate at 40 phr gave a Tg of 46 degrees Celsius and only 44.35% elongation.
Isobornyl esters lower the glass transition through a bulky terpene structure, while elongation also depends on compatibility, loading and how the alkyl chain packs with PVC chains. A compounder who selects on Tg alone would pick a different grade from one who selects on elongation.
What a formulator can take from this
- Screen each ester across at least three loadings. The ranking changed between 20, 40 and 60 phr.
- Do not use Tg reduction as a single efficiency metric. The lowest Tg grade did not give the best elongation.
- Keep the 190 to 260 degrees Celsius loss region in mind when setting processing temperature.
- Compare against both neat PVC and a commercial DOP control. The two baselines tell different stories.
- Expect a tensile strength penalty. Every ester grade fell below the 35.00 MPa of neat PVC.
- Check the acid chain length. Laurate, myristate, palmitate and stearate behaved differently at the same phr.
Limitations
This is a solution-cast film study with specimens about 0.20 mm thick and five tensile parallels per point. The camphene feed was not pure camphene, and the ester synthesis details were referred to earlier work rather than repeated in full. The paper reports that an acute oral toxicity assessment found the esters non-toxic but does not present the data in this article. Processing behavior in an industrial compounder, migration resistance, long-term aging and odor were not evaluated. The tensile and thermal results describe this formulation window, not a universal ranking of bio-based PVC plasticizers.
Bottom line
Isobornyl esters made from camphene do plasticize PVC, but the effect is strongly grade and loading dependent. At 60 phr the family brought Tg down to 31 to 39 degrees Celsius, and laurate at 40 phr approached the elongation of the DOP control. Strength always fell, some grades failed to plasticize at low loading, and every ester began to volatilize or decompose well before the main PVC degradation step. The numbers justify further screening rather than a drop-in replacement claim.
FAQ
What is an isobornyl ester plasticizer in this study?
It is an ester made by reacting camphene with a C12 to C18 fatty acid. The study prepared laurate, myristate, palmitate and stearate versions and tested each in PVC. The bulky isobornyl group comes from the terpene feed, and the fatty acid supplies the long alkyl chain.
Did these esters lower the glass transition of PVC?
Yes. Within each ester family the glass transition fell as loading rose. At a PVC to ester ratio of 100:60, values dropped to between 31 and 39 degrees Celsius. Isobornyl stearate at 60 phr gave the lowest value at 31 degrees Celsius.
How did they compare with DOP?
The DOP control at 60 phr reached 456% elongation at break and 25.00 MPa tensile strength. The closest isobornyl result was laurate at 40 phr with 448.10% elongation, but no ester matched the DOP combination of strength and stretch across all loadings.
Why did some formulations show no plasticizing effect?
The authors report formulation-dependent behavior. Myristate at 20 and 40 phr gave elongation below neat PVC, at 73.16% and 44.35%. The bulky isobornyl structure and the mismatch between ester and PVC chain packing appear to matter as much as loading.
What happened to tensile strength?
Every ester formulation reduced tensile strength relative to neat PVC at 35.00 MPa. Values ranged from 10.91 MPa for myristate at 20 phr to 34.39 MPa for stearate at 40 phr. A strength penalty is part of the trade-off with this family.
Is the thermal margin wide enough for processing?
The esters showed a separate weight-loss interval between 190 and 260 degrees Celsius, with peaks from 222 to 237 degrees Celsius. Main PVC degradation started around 281 degrees Celsius. The reported separation was 40 to 50 degrees Celsius, which is worth checking against your actual melt temperature.
Which ester performed best overall?
There is no single answer. Laurate at 40 phr gave the highest elongation among the esters at 448.10%. Stearate at 40 phr gave the highest tensile strength at 34.39 MPa and the lowest Tg at 60 phr. The best grade depends on which property you are targeting.
Were the esters made from renewable material?
The camphene feed is a terpene, and the study used C12 to C18 fatty acids. The authors frame the work around bio-derived feedstocks. The catalyst was titanium sulfate and the solvent in the PVC films was tetrahydrofuran, so the full formulation is not entirely bio-based.
What test standard was used for tensile properties?
Tensile testing followed GB/T 1040.1-2006 at 25 degrees Celsius and a crosshead speed of 10 mm per minute. Each result was the mean of five parallel specimens. Films were cast from solution and dried before testing.
Does a lower glass transition guarantee better flexibility here?
No. Stearate at 60 phr gave the lowest Tg but only 167.66% elongation. Elongation also depended on ester identity and loading. Glass transition is one signal, not a complete measure of plasticizing performance.
What was the role of the DOP control?
DOP at 60 phr provided a commercial benchmark. It reached 456% elongation with 25.00 MPa strength. Comparing against both neat PVC and DOP makes clear that the esters improve flexibility over PVC but do not reproduce the DOP balance in every grade.
What would I need to test before using these in production?
Check processing stability at your melt temperature, migration and extraction resistance, odor, long-term aging and compatibility with the rest of your package. This article reports solution-cast film data only and does not cover those industrial questions.
Comments
Post a Comment